Strange results w/ Bindy (header, list, footer)

[Christian Scharmach]

Hello!



I am using Camel-Bindy 2.22.0 and was trying to marshal a CSV file with following format:





HeaderColumn:headerColumn:headerColumn

BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn

BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn

FooterColumn;FooterColumn

[etc]



where "Body" can be one or two lines.



I created a CsvEntryHeader, CsvEntryFooter, CsvEntryBody file and a CsvPackage which shall hold them all together.

But I am getting strange results as soon as I add a CsvEntryBody.

Most likely because all of them have different count of columns (I guess).



I expect it to be:



HEADER;agency1;00.01;1

BODY

FOOTER;agency1;;1



but it actually is



HEADER;agency1;00.01;1

BODY;agency1;;1

FOOTER;agency1;00.01;1



Test-Case:



https://github.com/c9pr3/bindy-bug-test



Any help appreciated!

[Claus Ibsen]

Hi

Ah okay, so are you saying that the footer has some body data or what?
Maybe you can make the test case simpler to follow for us?

Also can you try in your unit test to not do 2 testing in one method,
but split them up into 2 methods, as maybe mutating the test for the
2nd test cause a side-effect or something.

Post by Christian Scharmach
Hello!
HeaderColumn:headerColumn:headerColumn
BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn
BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn
FooterColumn;FooterColumn
[etc]
where "Body" can be one or two lines.
I created a CsvEntryHeader, CsvEntryFooter, CsvEntryBody file and a CsvPackage which shall hold them all together.
But I am getting strange results as soon as I add a CsvEntryBody.
Most likely because all of them have different count of columns (I guess).
HEADER;agency1;00.01;1
BODY
FOOTER;agency1;;1
but it actually is
HEADER;agency1;00.01;1
BODY;agency1;;1
FOOTER;agency1;00.01;1
https://github.com/c9pr3/bindy-bug-test
Any help appreciated!

[Christian Scharmach]

Hi Claus,

Post by Claus Ibsen
Ah okay, so are you saying that the footer has some body data or what?

exactly!

It seems like parts of the header are "sticky" and get passed further down to body and footer.



I splitted the test-cases into two separated ones. Hope that helps!



Best Regards,

Chris



Am 30.07.18, 17:06 schrieb "Claus Ibsen" <***@gmail.com>:



Hi



Ah okay, so are you saying that the footer has some body data or what?

Maybe you can make the test case simpler to follow for us?



Also can you try in your unit test to not do 2 testing in one method,

but split them up into 2 methods, as maybe mutating the test for the

2nd test cause a side-effect or something.

Post by Claus Ibsen
Hello!
HeaderColumn:headerColumn:headerColumn
BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn
BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn;BodyColumn
FooterColumn;FooterColumn
[etc]
where "Body" can be one or two lines.
I created a CsvEntryHeader, CsvEntryFooter, CsvEntryBody file and a CsvPackage which shall hold them all together.
But I am getting strange results as soon as I add a CsvEntryBody.
Most likely because all of them have different count of columns (I guess).
HEADER;agency1;00.01;1
BODY
FOOTER;agency1;;1
but it actually is
HEADER;agency1;00.01;1
BODY;agency1;;1
FOOTER;agency1;00.01;1
https://github.com/c9pr3/bindy-bug-test
Any help appreciated!

--

Claus Ibsen

-----------------

http://davsclaus.com @davsclaus

Camel in Action 2: https://www.manning.com/ibsen2